I used to believe I could tell when my husband was lying.
That evening, I wasn't so sure.
It was 5:40, and I was standing in our townhouse kitchen, trying to wrap a birthday present without making a mess of it.
The paper was silver.
The box underneath was cardboard.
Inside was a puzzle I had already chosen, and I was trying to get the corners folded neatly enough that the tape wouldn't show.
I remember those little details because everything seemed ordinary until I looked up.
Mark's phone was sitting upright beside the sugar canister.
The front of it faced my chair.
Not the sink.
Not the window.
My chair.
I stopped with a strip of tape stuck to my finger.
For a moment, I just stared at the phone.
Its screen looked dark from where I stood.
I couldn't tell whether the camera was doing anything.
That bothered me more than I wanted to admit.
Our daughter was sitting at the kitchen table.
She was two years old, and she had no interest in the wrapping paper or the puzzle box.
She had her yellow hairbrush in one hand and a stuffed rabbit in the other.
She was brushing its ears.
Slowly.
Carefully.
As though the rabbit had asked her to do it.
I watched her for a second before turning back toward Mark.
He was standing near the sink.
A little spiral notebook lay open beside the dish soap.
He had a blue pen in his hand.
I could see that he was writing numbers that looked like times.
One under another.
I hadn't noticed the notebook when I started wrapping.
I hadn't noticed the phone either.
Looking back, that is what troubles me.
Both things had been close enough for me to see.
I was simply busy doing something else.
I asked him why his phone was aimed at the place where I sat.
Mark looked at me.
Then he looked at the phone.
He didn't seem surprised by the question.
He said he had been inspecting the camera for dirt.
That was his explanation.
Dust on the front lens.
I glanced at the sugar canister again.
The phone was still standing there.
If he had finished checking the lens, I didn't understand why he had left it facing the table.
I wanted to ask.
Instead, I looked at the notebook.
Mark shut it.
Not quickly enough to seem frightened.
Just quickly enough that I couldn't read what he had written.
Then he put it into his back pocket.
That small movement changed the way I felt about the phone.
One thing might have been harmless.
Two things together were harder to ignore.
Mark adjusted his glasses.
He did that often when he was thinking about what to say.
I knew the gesture well.
I had watched him do it over ordinary matters, over disagreements, and over questions he didn't seem eager to answer.
This time, he brought up our argument from Tuesday.
He asked whether I was still upset.
Then he asked how much sleep I had managed afterward.
I stood there with the tape in my hand.
I had asked about a phone.
He was asking about my sleep.
The difference seemed small at first.
Then I heard how carefully he had put the question.
I answered him.
Six hours.
That was how long I had slept.
I didn't raise my voice.
I didn't put down the wrapping paper.
I gave him the number because it was the truth, and because I wanted to understand why he had asked.
Mark watched me.
There was something about his expression that made me feel I was being measured.
I couldn't explain it then.
I can only explain what I noticed.
He had a notebook with times written in it.
He had a phone pointed toward my chair.
And when I questioned him, he asked me to describe my state of mind.
I looked toward the sink.
I asked why he was recording times in that notebook.
He didn't answer.
He turned on the water.
There was a coffee mug beside the faucet.
He picked it up and began washing it.
I knew he had already cleaned that mug earlier.
I had seen it.
The water ran over the ceramic while he moved it around in his hand.
I stood with the wrapping paper unfinished.
The sound of the faucet filled the space between us.
It was a simple thing.
A husband rinsing a mug.
Nothing special.
But he was doing it instead of answering me.
I looked down at the puzzle box again.
The paper had slipped loose at one corner.
I pressed it back into place.
I remember feeling foolish for caring whether the corner looked neat when I couldn't get a straight answer to two ordinary questions.
I didn't know what Mark intended.
I still had no proof that the phone was recording.
I only knew its position.
I only knew what I had seen him writing.
And I knew that neither explanation had satisfied me.
I looked over at our daughter.
She had moved the yellow brush from one rabbit ear to the other.
Her small hand kept working.
She didn't look up.
She didn't know that her father and I had been arguing.
She didn't know what had happened on Tuesday, either.
She was simply sitting at our table with her toy.
I wanted the kitchen to feel normal again.
I wanted Mark to put down the mug and tell me what the notebook was for.
I wanted the phone moved away from my chair.
Those were not large things to want.
But I didn't ask again immediately.
Instead, I looked toward the toaster.
There was an empty stretch of counter beside it.
That was where I had left the white bakery box in the morning.
I had picked up the cake from Miller's.
I remembered setting the box down there.
Now it was gone.
I looked once more, although I could see perfectly well that the space was empty.
Then I asked Mark where he had put it.
He was still at the sink.
The faucet was running.
Before he could say anything, his phone vibrated against the granite.
The sound was short.
Hard.
It made me look back toward the sugar canister.
The screen lit up.
Elaine's name appeared.
I saw it clearly.
Mark reached for the phone.
He picked it up and moved away from the counter.
He took three steps toward the laundry alcove.
Not into another room.
Just far enough to turn his shoulder away from me.
I watched him answer.
His voice changed.
It became quieter.
I could still hear him.
He told Elaine that I was calm at that moment.
Those words stayed with me.
He could have said we were getting ready.
He could have said he was in the kitchen.
He could have told her anything about the evening.
Instead, he described me.
Calm.
At that moment.
I looked at the chair.
The one the phone had been facing.
I looked at the notebook pocket of his jeans.
Then I looked at the place where the cake should have been.
Mark kept speaking.
He told Elaine we would arrive by six-thirty.
I stared at him.
We.
He had said we.
The call hadn't answered my question about the cake.
It hadn't explained the notebook.
It hadn't explained the camera.
But it gave me one fact I hadn't known when I began wrapping the present.
Mark had told Elaine that we were going somewhere together.
He had given her a time.
And he had done it without telling me where we were going.
Click here to continue reading: PART 2: My Husband Told Elaine I Was Calm, and I Realized He Was Describing Me Instead of Answering My Questions
I Was Wrapping a Birthday Present When I Noticed My Husband Had Positioned His Phone to Record Me
Part 1 of 10

