PART 2 – My Husband Told Elaine I Was Calm, and I Realized He Was Describing Me Instead of Answering My Questions

I kept my eyes on Mark while he stood in the laundry alcove.

He still had his back partly turned.

His phone was against his ear.

I couldn't hear Elaine.

I could hear the faucet because he had left it running.

The mug was still near the sink.

The silver paper was still open beneath my hands.

Nothing in the kitchen had changed very much.

But I was no longer thinking about the present.

I was thinking about one word.

Calm.

That was how Mark had described me.

Not busy.

Not wrapping a gift.

Not standing beside our daughter.

Calm.

I had never liked having someone else explain my feelings while I was standing close enough to speak for myself.

That evening, it felt particularly strange.

I had asked Mark why his camera was pointed at my chair.

He had told me he was checking for dust.

I had asked about the notebook.

He had washed a mug.

I had asked about the cake.

Then Elaine called.

Each time I asked for a simple fact, the conversation moved somewhere else.

I hadn't noticed that pattern immediately.

I was noticing it now.

Our daughter made a small movement at the table.

The brush slipped from the rabbit's ear.

She picked it up and tried again.

I watched her because it was easier than staring at Mark.

She was doing the same thing she had been doing before the phone rang.

She had no reason to suspect anything unusual.

I envied that for a moment.

Then I felt ashamed of the thought.

She was two.

Of course she didn't understand.

It was my job to understand what was happening around her.

I turned toward the counter again.

The wrapping paper had developed a crease across the middle.

I smoothed it with my palm.

There was no reason to keep working on the gift while Mark was on the phone.

But I needed something to do with my hands.

I folded one side of the paper.

Then I unfolded it.

The tape stuck to my thumb.

I pulled it loose.

I remember how irritated I became with that tiny piece of tape.

Not because it hurt.

Because I couldn't make it stay where I wanted.

Mark had still not returned to the sink.

I could see part of his face beyond his shoulder.

His glasses caught the kitchen light.

I had known him long enough to recognize the way he held himself when he didn't want a conversation interrupted.

He had turned away from me before.

That alone wasn't remarkable.

People turn away while making phone calls.

People speak quietly.

People want privacy.

I knew all that.

I also knew he had said I was calm.

That was the part I couldn't make ordinary.

I wondered what Elaine had asked him.

Had she asked whether I was ready?

Had she asked whether our daughter was ready?

Had she asked something about the cake?

I didn't know.

I couldn't hear her.

I could only work with Mark's half of the conversation.

That mattered.

I had to remind myself of it.

I didn't want to turn guesses into facts simply because I was uncomfortable.

The facts were enough to trouble me.

A phone pointed toward my chair.

A notebook containing times.

A question about my sleep.

A missing cake.

And now a conversation about my behavior.

I looked at the clock.

It was already after 5:40.

Six-thirty wasn't far away.

Mark had said we would be there by then.

He hadn't asked whether I wanted to go.

He hadn't told me what arrangements he had made.

I didn't even know whether he meant that our daughter was coming.

I hated that I had to wonder.

The kitchen was our shared space.

The child at the table was our daughter.

The cake had been picked up for the birthday.

Yet somehow I had become the person asking where everything was and what was supposed to happen next.

Mark's notebook bothered me again.

I tried to picture the page.

It had been small.

Spiral binding at the top.

Blue writing.

Times in a column.

I hadn't read the entries.

I couldn't say what they represented.

For all I knew, they could have been reminders.

But when I questioned him, he hadn't offered that explanation.

He had put the notebook away.

That was what I remembered most clearly.

Not what was written.

What he did when I noticed it.

The faucet continued running.

I wanted to reach over and turn it off.

Instead, I stood still.

I could feel my own breathing.

I wondered whether Mark would call me agitated if I moved too quickly.

That thought frightened me a little.

Not because anyone had accused me of anything.

Because I was beginning to judge my movements through the words he might use about them.

I looked at the chair again.

Before that evening, it was simply where I sat at our kitchen table.

It was where I ate breakfast.

Where I folded paper.

Where I watched our daughter play.

Now I was thinking about it as the place a camera had been aimed.

I didn't like that change.

I couldn't undo it by telling myself the phone might not have been recording.

The possibility was already there.

I thought about Tuesday.

We had argued.

That was true.

Mark had mentioned it.

He had linked it to my sleep without explaining why.

I did not want to retell that argument in my head.

I did not want to give it more importance than the questions I was asking now.

Whatever had happened on Tuesday, it did not tell me where the cake was.

It did not explain the notebook.

And it did not answer why Elaine needed to know whether I was calm.

I pressed my palm against the silver paper.

It made a faint crinkling sound.

Our daughter looked toward me.

For a moment, I thought she wanted the present.

But she went back to brushing the rabbit.

I kept watching her hands.

The brush was yellow plastic.

The rabbit was soft.

The motions were familiar.

There was comfort in seeing something I understood without needing anyone to explain it.

I looked over at the toaster.

The empty place beside it seemed larger than it had a few minutes earlier.

The cake box had been white.

I had seen it there in the morning.

I had been the one to collect it from Miller's.

That was all certain.

I didn't know who had moved it.

I didn't know when.

And I didn't know where it had gone.

It should have been an easy question.

Where was the cake?

I had not expected that question to remain unanswered.

Mark shifted in the alcove.

I stopped watching his shoulders and looked at the phone in his hand.

He was still speaking to Elaine.

I couldn't make out any more words.

I found myself wanting to walk over and ask him to repeat what he had just said.

I didn't.

I stayed by the counter.

Looking back, I wish I could say that was a deliberate choice.

It wasn't.

I was uncertain.

I wanted to understand before I challenged anything else.

I had already asked three questions and received no useful answers.

I was beginning to wonder whether asking a fourth would change anything.

The time Mark had given Elaine was precise.

Six-thirty.

Not later.

Not sometime that evening.

He had told her we would arrive by six-thirty.

That sounded like a plan already made.

I couldn't prove anything else.

I couldn't say whether Elaine knew about the phone.

I couldn't say whether the notebook had anything to do with her call.

I couldn't say why the cake was missing.

I knew only that Mark had agreed to a time, and I hadn't been part of that conversation.

For the first time that evening, I stopped trying to make the wrapping paper look neat.

I placed the tape on the counter.

I left the loose silver corner alone.

I looked toward my husband and understood that I needed an answer before I could continue pretending we were simply preparing for a birthday.

Where were we supposed to be at six-thirty?


Click here to continue reading: PART 3: The Missing Cake, the Notebook Beside the Sink, and the Camera Facing My Chair Suddenly Felt Connected

Story Parts

I Was Wrapping a Birthday Present When I Noticed My Husband Had Positioned His Phone to Record Me

Part 2 of 10

Previous: Part 1
Next: Part 3

One Comment on “PART 2 – My Husband Told Elaine I Was Calm, and I Realized He Was Describing Me Instead of Answering My Questions”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *