I wanted Mark to turn around.
I wanted him to finish speaking with Elaine and tell me what was going on.
I wanted a plain answer.
No more than that.
The kitchen was still quiet apart from the faucet and his voice.
Our daughter was sitting at the table.
The yellow brush moved across the rabbit's ears.
I had been watching her for what felt like a long time.
In truth, only a few minutes had passed since I first looked at Mark's phone.
That was another thing I remember.
How quickly an ordinary evening could become difficult to understand.
I hadn't started an argument.
I hadn't gone looking through Mark's belongings.
I was wrapping a present.
Then I noticed a phone in an unusual position.
I asked about it.
From that moment, every answer seemed to lead somewhere I hadn't intended to go.
The camera question became a question about Tuesday.
The notebook question became the sound of running water.
The cake question was interrupted by Elaine.
And Elaine's call introduced a plan I didn't know about.
I couldn't say what the plan was.
I couldn't say why Mark had described me the way he did.
I couldn't say that anything more serious was happening.
I just couldn't make those facts fit together.
I looked at the chair again.
It was an ordinary kitchen chair.
I had sat there earlier.
I would have thought nothing of seeing Mark's phone on the counter if its camera had been facing somewhere else.
But it hadn't been.
It faced the place where I sat.
That remained true no matter how often I reconsidered his explanation.
He said he was checking the lens.
Perhaps he was.
Perhaps the position meant nothing.
But the phone hadn't been in his hand when I noticed it.
It had been standing upright.
That was what I saw.
I didn't want to forget it simply because Mark had given me a different way to think about it.
The same was true of the notebook.
I hadn't imagined the blue writing.
I had seen the numbers.
I had seen him shut the cover.
I had seen him put it into his pocket.
Those actions were real.
What they meant was still unknown.
I kept that distinction in my mind.
The cake was easier.
A white box had been left by the toaster.
Now it wasn't there.
I didn't have to interpret anything to know that.
I had picked it up from Miller's myself.
I remembered bringing it into the townhouse.
I remembered setting it down.
I looked at the empty counter once more.
I wanted to ask Mark about it again.
But he was still occupied with Elaine.
I could see the phone near his cheek.
His shoulder blocked part of his face.
I didn't know whether he realized I had heard him describe me as calm.
I wondered whether he would have used that word if I had been standing beside him.
I couldn't answer that either.
I thought about Tuesday again.
We had argued.
Mark had referred to it in the kitchen.
He had asked whether I slept afterward.
I had said six hours.
There had been nothing dishonest about my answer.
I knew how long I had slept.
Still, I wished he hadn't asked the question while his phone was positioned the way it was.
It made the exchange feel different.
I didn't know whether the camera had been active.
I didn't know whether anything I said had been captured.
I couldn't accuse him of recording me without proof.
But I could acknowledge that the possibility disturbed me.
It did.
More than I wanted to admit.
I thought about our daughter and the way he had spoken to Elaine.
He hadn't mentioned her in the part of the conversation I heard.
He had spoken about me.
Then he had promised that we would arrive by six-thirty.
Who did he mean by we?
Himself and me?
All three of us?
I didn't know.
It would have been easy to choose an answer and treat it as fact.
I resisted that.
I didn't want to be wrong about something important.
The yellow hairbrush slipped from our daughter's hand.
She caught it against the table before it fell.
I watched her fingers close around the handle.
Then she continued brushing the rabbit.
The small movement brought me back to the room.
I was still standing beside the present.
Mark was still in the alcove.
Our daughter was still playing.
There was no visible emergency.
No raised voices.
No broken dishes.
No one was running.
But I no longer felt comfortable continuing as though nothing had happened.
I didn't want to create a scene in front of our daughter.
I also didn't want to swallow my questions just because Mark appeared unwilling to answer them.
Those two wishes were pulling against each other.
I looked at the silver paper.
The box underneath was still partly exposed.
I had left the gift unfinished.
There was nothing preventing me from completing it.
I knew that.
But I couldn't make myself care about the wrapping.
I had more important things to understand.
Where was the cake?
Why had Mark been writing times?
Why had his phone been pointed toward my chair?
And where exactly had he agreed to take us?
I didn't expect one question to answer all the others.
I wanted each one answered on its own.
That seemed reasonable to me.
I wasn't asking him to explain what I felt.
I could do that myself.
I was asking him about things he had done or said.
The difference mattered.
I looked over at him.
His glasses were still visible beyond the turn of his shoulder.
I thought about how he had straightened them earlier.
He had done it before asking whether I was tired.
It was such a familiar movement.
I had always associated it with him thinking.
Now I remembered the notebook disappearing into his pocket just before he did it.
A familiar gesture had become attached to an unfamiliar moment.
I didn't like how quickly that happened.
I didn't want to begin doubting everything he did.
I didn't want our whole marriage reduced to watching his hands and listening for changes in his voice.
I had no reason to make a judgment that large from a few minutes in the kitchen.
So I didn't.
I stayed with the facts.
The phone.
The notebook.
The missing cake.
Elaine.
Six-thirty.
I repeated them silently.
Not as proof of something.
As the things I still needed explained.
The running faucet caught my attention again.
Mark had left it on when he moved away.
The coffee mug remained beside the sink.
I remembered watching him rinse it rather than answer me.
I remembered how ordinary the movement looked.
I wanted to know whether he had simply been avoiding a difficult conversation.
That was possible.
I wanted to know whether there was another reason.
That was possible too.
I couldn't choose between those possibilities yet.
I glanced at our daughter.
She was absorbed in her rabbit.
I was glad for it.
She had done nothing wrong.
She deserved a birthday evening that didn't revolve around the tension between her parents.
I looked at the clock.
Mark had given Elaine a time.
Six-thirty.
I hadn't agreed to anything.
I hadn't even been told where we were expected.
That was the one part I could act on without guessing.
I could decide not to treat his arrangement as mine until he explained it.
I could ask where he meant to take us.
I could ask about the cake again.
I could wait for answers before continuing with the preparations.
That was not an accusation.
It was a decision.
I put the loose tape down.
I folded the silver wrapping paper away from the puzzle box so it wouldn't tear.
Then I left it unfinished on the counter.
I didn't touch Mark's notebook.
I didn't reach for his phone.
I didn't interrupt his conversation with Elaine.
I stood beside the present and waited for the chance to speak to him directly.
I still didn't know what the camera was for.
I still didn't know why he had written those times.
I still didn't know where the birthday cake had gone.
But I knew something about my own position in that kitchen.
I had been asked to explain myself while my questions went unanswered.
I wasn't willing to continue that way.
When Mark finished speaking with Elaine, I intended to ask him about six-thirty.
And this time, I intended to keep the conversation on the question I had actually asked.
Click here to continue reading: PART 5: When Mark Finally Ended His Call With Elaine, I Realized the Birthday Celebration Was Already Arranged Without My Agreement
I Was Wrapping a Birthday Present When I Noticed My Husband Had Positioned His Phone to Record Me
Part 4 of 10

