PART 2 – ALDEN ASKED WHY HIS NAME WAS MISSING FROM THE AGREEMENT, AND MY ANSWER LEFT HIM WITH NOTHING TO SAY

Alden looked at me as though he had found something he wasn't supposed to see.

He still had the lease in his hand.

I could see my name printed on the page.

He could see it too.

That was what bothered him.

He stared at me.

"What am I supposed to make of this, Joanne?"

I looked at the document.

"It's an agreement to lease the pasture."

He gave me a hard look.

"I know what a lease looks like."

I didn't answer.

He glanced down again.

"Then explain why it only names you."

There it was.

The question I had known was coming.

I kept my hands together on the table.

"Because the property is recorded in my name."

Alden stopped moving.

He looked at me.

Then he looked at the paper.

His mouth opened slightly.

Nothing came out.

I had been married to that man for forty-five years.

I knew how he sounded when he was angry.

I knew how he sounded when he thought someone was wasting his time.

I knew the tone he used when he expected an answer and believed he had every right to demand one.

But I wasn't accustomed to silence from him.

Not that kind.

He stood there with the lease in his hand, unable to find a response.

I didn't fill the space.

I didn't say the words again.

He had heard me.

That much was clear.

My name was on the deed.

His wasn't.

It wasn't an argument about how we felt.

It was a fact about the ownership of forty acres in Marion County, Arkansas.

And the agreement he held had been made between me and Miriam Yoder.

I could tell that Alden wanted to move the conversation somewhere else.

Somewhere he felt more comfortable.

Somewhere he could speak about the farm as if the ownership had already been settled in his favor.

But the document gave him no help.

He had read it himself.

I hadn't put the words into his mouth.

He was the one who had said my name aloud.

He was the one who had reached the line identifying me as the sole owner.

And he was the one who had stopped.

I kept thinking about that.

For years, I had allowed an ordinary word to carry more weight than it should.

Ours.

It was such an easy word in a marriage.

Our kitchen.

Our home.

Our farm.

But that word could hide a great deal.

Sometimes it described a life shared by two people.

Sometimes it described what one person assumed about the other.

And sometimes it made an important distinction disappear.

I had allowed that distinction to go unspoken for a long time.

Now Alden was standing in front of me, trying to understand why a lease involving the pasture did not include his name.

I didn't feel the need to apologize.

That was new.

Usually, I would have tried to make things sound less serious.

I might have softened an answer.

I might have explained the same point three different ways, hoping one of them would keep the conversation calm.

But I had already given him the answer.

There wasn't another one.

Alden shifted the document in his hand.

He examined it again.

I watched his eyes move over the page.

Forty acres.

Marion County.

Joanne Kittle.

Miriam Yoder.

A pasture lease.

Every part of it belonged to the same simple explanation.

The land was mine.

The lease named me accordingly.

Alden was not identified as an owner because he was not named on the deed.

I couldn't make it any plainer.

He looked almost offended by the simplicity of it.

That was what I noticed most.

It wasn't as though I had given him a complicated answer.

I hadn't brought up some matter he needed days to understand.

I had told him a basic fact.

And the fact was enough to stop him.

For a few moments, anyway.

I waited.

The paper remained between us.

I could feel myself wanting to speak again, just to break the quiet.

Old habits don't disappear because a person decides they've had enough.

They stay close.

They offer familiar ways out of uncomfortable moments.

I could have said something reassuring.

I could have told him not to worry.

I could have tried to make the lease sound unimportant.

But that would have defeated the purpose of telling him the truth.

So I kept quiet.

Alden's expression shifted.

The surprise was still there.

Something else had joined it.

Disbelief.

He looked at me as though he was waiting for me to admit that I had misunderstood the document.

I knew that look.

He didn't have to explain it.

He expected the person sitting across from him to retreat.

To say she had spoken too quickly.

To acknowledge that he understood the farm better than she did.

I wasn't going to do that.

Not with the lease sitting plainly in front of us.

Not when my name was there for him to read.

Alden lowered his eyes to the page one more time.

Then his face changed.

His lips pulled into a smile that wasn't warm.

I knew what was coming before I heard it.

He began to laugh.

And I realized the silence hadn't meant he accepted what I'd said.

It only meant he hadn't decided how to dismiss it yet.


Click here to continue reading: PART 3: WHEN ALDEN LAUGHED AT THE IDEA THAT I OWNED THE PASTURE, I FINALLY STOPPED CORRECTING MYSELF TO PLEASE HIM

Story Parts

MY HUSBAND HELD A PIECE OF PAPER IN OUR KITCHEN, AND I KNEW FORTY-FIVE YEARS OF SILENCE WERE ABOUT TO END

Part 2 of 10

Previous: Part 1
Next: Part 3

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *